Day 1: Brain Drain Crisis in Post-2021 Afghanistan_TeamD

Afghanistan Experiments in Summer 2023
,
141

Taliban should lay down and decide to create an inclusive government

is probably not correct.
The given text is not factual because it states that the Taliban should lay down and decide to create an inclusive government. However, the provided evidences suggest that the Taliban have no interest in giving in to demands for a less repressive government and that a transition to a more inclusive government is highly unlikely.

everyone can conduct a business without any consideration of insecurity or instability

is probably not correct.
The given text states that everyone can conduct a business without any consideration of insecurity or instability. However, the provided evidences clearly indicate that starting a business brings financial insecurity and instability. Layoffs and economic conditions also demonstrate that job security is not guaranteed. Therefore, the given text is non-factual.

142

Investment of international organizations in Afghanistan will also help reduction of brain drain as these people will get employed here

143

Investment of international organizations in Afghanistan will help reduction of brain drain

is probably not correct.
The given text states that investment of international organizations in Afghanistan will help reduce brain drain. However, the provided evidences suggest that brain drain continues to be a problem in Afghanistan, with a mass exodus of professionals since the Taliban takeover. Therefore, the given text is not factual.

144

As you noticed what are the ways to prevet from illegal immigration, in my view, firstly, government should solve the people’s problem and care about them and their needs, and if the government can’t do these actions perfectly, the next way is to provide the legal way of immigration and other opportunities and let the people to have access to their passports easily and travel anywhere they want, by this the risk of immigration especially illegal immigration decreases.

145

That’s true, if agencies and private sector invest in youths create job opportunities.

146

I think if this political condition of taliban continues more, it can be a good way to youth for immigaret.
Youth in out of Aghanistan can do jobless, innovation, creation, education, economic improvement and another useful options. although this is not a good solution but the youth are have to do it.

147

You mentioned a good point, but I don’t think that the government support the women to promote their business, besides they forbids women from everything.

148

The political condition of Taliban can be a good way for youth to immigrate

is probably not correct.
The given text states that the political condition of the Taliban can be a good way for youth to immigrate. However, the provided evidences suggest that the Taliban’s political condition is characterized by suppression of free speech, organized political activity, political exclusion, economic deprivation, and human suffering. There is no evidence to support the claim that the Taliban’s political condition is a good way for youth to immigrate.

Youth in Afghanistan can do jobless

is probably not correct.
The given text is not factual because it states that youth in Afghanistan can do jobless, which is grammatically incorrect and does not make sense. The correct phrase should be ‘youth in Afghanistan can be jobless’ or ‘youth in Afghanistan can be unemployed’.

Youth in Afghanistan can do creation

is probably not correct.
The given text states that youth in Afghanistan can do creation. However, there is no evidence provided that supports this claim. The evidences only mention the aspirations and challenges faced by Afghan youth, but there is no specific mention of their ability to create. Therefore, the factual accuracy of the given text is questionable.

Youth in Afghanistan can do education

is probably not correct.
The given text states that youth in Afghanistan can do education. However, the provided evidences indicate that girls and women in Afghanistan have been deprived of the right to attend secondary school since the Taliban’s takeover in 2021. Only girls aged 12 and under have been allowed to go to school. This contradicts the claim made in the given text.

Youth in Afghanistan can do another useful options

is probably not correct.
The given text is not factual because it is grammatically incorrect and does not provide any specific information about the useful options available to youth in Afghanistan.

Youth in Afghanistan have to do it

is probably not correct.
The given text is not factual because it lacks specific information and context. It is unclear what ‘it’ refers to and what actions the youth in Afghanistan are supposed to do.

149

Providing a safe and reliable environment for the professionals of Afghanistan would help them in not fleeing Afghanistan.

150

The Taliban should decide to create an inclusive government

is probably not correct.
The given text is not factual because the evidences suggest that the Taliban have no interest in creating an inclusive government.

Everyone can do their business regardless of insecurity

is probably not correct.
The given text is non-factual because the evidences provided state that everyone feels insecure at some point in their lives, regardless of their success or wealth. Therefore, it is not True that everyone can do their business regardless of insecurity.

Everyone can do their business regardless of instability

is probably not correct.
The given text states that everyone can do their business regardless of instability. However, the provided evidences suggest that political stability is not the norm and that instability can have an impact on businesses. Therefore, the given text is not factual.

151

Yes we had these problems befor in last governement also but now its more than before .

152

But This is the way to solve the problems.

153

we had problems before in last government

is probably not correct.
The given text does not provide any specific information or evidence to support the claim that there were problems in the last government. Without any specific details or evidence, it is difficult to determine the factuality of this statement.

problems are more than before

is probably not correct.
The given text is not specific enough to determine its factuality. It simply states that ‘problems are more than before’ without providing any context or evidence to support this claim. Without more information, it is difficult to determine whether this statement is factual or not.

154

I agree with you
And what other ways are there for youth to do for themselves.

155

other ways for youth to do for themselves

is probably not correct.
The given text is not factual because it is too vague and does not provide any specific information or evidence to support the claim.

156

One of the solutions can be giving up the orders that cause the isolation of the youth. So that they their rights and freedom and continue to live in their country.

157

In this situation not brain drain crisis creat the challenge but the current situation force them to do this and think about leaving the country.

158

I strongly agree with you now what’s the solution about this situation, what women do to themselves

159

A good example of brain drain from a dictatorial society can be found in Afghanistan. in Afghanistan, unfortunately brain drain took place after the arrival of the Taliban, many educated person who tried and learned science in the last twenty years were all forced to leave the country to protect themselves.
If we examine the depth of the issue, we will see that the Taliban is a group whose existence is dangerous for the people of the society and is against the study of science and makes the study of science specific to a specific phenomenon and relates it to religion. So this place is a dangerous environment for a educated people that may kill them.
So brain drain happens when the society and the government are inappropriate and dangerous for them.

1 Like
160

Now this matter depends on the extent to which the Taliban government allows foreign institutions to operate; For example, due to the fact that the number of female employees in institutions is decreasing day by day, maybe the day will come when the gate of the institutions will be closed by this dictatorial government.