Day 1: Brain Drain Crisis in Post-2021 Afghanistan_TeamD

In any case, including brain drain, 99% of them are men. So what do you think the women who have disappeared from the scene the most and their rights have been taken away should do? They don’t even have the ability to immigrate, while they are half of our society and have rights.

99% of them are men

is probably not correct.
The given text states that 99% of them are men, but there is no evidence provided to support this claim. The provided evidences only mention the men to women ratio in different age groups and the expected sex ratio at birth. Therefore, we cannot determine the factuality of the given text based on the provided evidences.

women have disappeared from the scene the most

is probably not correct.
The given text does not provide any specific information or evidence to support the claim that women have disappeared from the scene the most. Without any supporting evidence, it is not possible to determine the factuality of this statement.

their rights have been taken away

is probably not correct.
The given text is not factual because it states that ‘their rights have been taken away’, which implies that someone’s rights have been completely removed. However, according to the provided evidence, rights by their nature cannot be taken away and every human has human rights regardless of the situation or circumstances surrounding them.

women don’t even have the ability to immigrate

is probably not correct.
The given text is not factual because it states that women don’t even have the ability to immigrate, which is contradicted by the provided evidence that immigrant women come from all over the world and outnumber immigrant men. They are more likely than men to come to the United States through the family-based immigration system and are more likely to become U.S. citizens. Over one-third of immigrant women aged 25 and older have a bachelor’s degree or more education.

Good quality of education plus post studies employment opportunities would either stop or slow down the brain drain in Afghanistan.

Good quality of education would stop or slow down the brain drain in Afghanistan

is probably not correct.
The given text states that good quality of education would stop or slow down the brain drain in Afghanistan. The provided evidence mentions that the imposition of restrictions on education rights has had a devastating effect, leading to brain drain. Therefore, the evidence contradicts the claim made in the given text.

Post studies employment opportunities would stop or slow down the brain drain in Afghanistan

is probably not correct.
The given text states that post-studies employment opportunities would stop or slow down the brain drain in Afghanistan. The evidence provided mentions the brain drain in Afghanistan and the need to halt or reduce it. However, there is no specific mention of post-studies employment opportunities as a solution to the brain drain. Therefore, the given text is not supported by the provided evidence.

Afghanistan is also one of the less developed countries that every year its young, expert, and productive manpower migrates to different countries of the world. Unfortunately, this trend has increased in recent years due to war political, economic, and social instability, and loss of opportunities.

I think this is not correct, because nothing is predictable; It is possible for Afghanistan to progress in the future and it depends on our people how much they try.

nothing is predictable

is probably not correct.
The given text ‘nothing is predictable’ is a general statement that implies that absolutely nothing can be predicted. However, the provided evidences suggest that while not everything is predictable with 100% certainty, many things can be predicted to a high degree of accuracy. The evidences mention that observations can become theories and estimate outcomes with a high degree of accuracy (95-99%). Therefore, the given text is not factual.

Loss of tax revenue is one of important affections of brain drain so the government should start working for ending it.

The collective migration of human resources from one country to another country or countries has many reasons: People migrate from one country to another due to poverty, tyranny, unemployment, and social disruptions, which are called push factors.

Good governance and health financing can also help in slowing down the brain drain.

1 Like

Good governance can help in slowing down the brain drain

is probably not correct.
The given text is a statement that suggests a causal relationship between good governance and slowing down brain drain. To determine the factuality of this statement, we can refer to the provided evidences. The evidences mention that corruption is the primary driver of brain drain, outweighing the effects of other governance qualities. This suggests that good governance alone may not be sufficient to slow down brain drain. Therefore, the given text may not be entirely factual.

It doesn’t matter how much the people of Afghanistan try it depends on the current government that what they do in Afghanistan about women which are at home .

but this claim is wrong, becouse past twenty yeras was good, becouse in this past twenty years Afghanistan improved acording to knowledge, democracy, freedom of speech and etc. and it is the Taliban claim that they said when we come to Kabul the war ended, that its unacceptable for Afghan people. in the past twenty years Taliban fight with Afghan people and government snd still they fight with the specific group in Afghanistan.

1 Like

That may cause illegal migration, people try to find some other ways

The another solution is Small Bussines (SMEs) creation and Income Generation Assessment (IGA).
The Internal and external organization shuould provide this items and programs for whose need them. It can be very useful for youth generation and jobless of them.

I think the biggest brain drain is, people are poor they are unemployed they must to migration because they don’t have other way most of the people which leave the country now they have job. The current government should think about that how they lose the talented people day by day, since 2021 most of our talented and educated people migrated. Unfortunately I can say that our current government don’t have educated people as much as past.

1 Like

My goal is different from searching to your perception.
Women is another issue and crisis that needs a long meeting.

in current situation even people do not know that what will happen for tomorrow. So how they should take plane for their futures. As you know that now both young generation even put them selves in danger to leave Afghanistan. We shoud not forget that the life of young educated people by coming of Taliban disappeared.

The claim that Afghanistan improved according to knowledge, democracy, freedom of speech in the past twenty years is wrong

is probably not correct.
The given text claims that Afghanistan improved in terms of knowledge, democracy, and freedom of speech in the past twenty years. However, the provided evidence suggests that there are still significant challenges and shortcomings in these areas. The evidence mentions that democracy and freedom of speech are missing, and that key Afghan institutions need to establish themselves. These evidences contradict the claim made in the given text.

That may cause illegal migration

is probably not correct.
The given text is not factual because it does not provide any evidence or reasoning to support the claim that illegal migration may be caused. The text is a statement without any supporting information.