To put it simply, if the “international community” opens its doors to the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, in the battle between the survivors of the central government of Afghanistan and a powerful militia group, the place of the government and militias will change in the blink of an eye. In such a situation, the Taliban regime becomes a legitimate government, which has the right to monopolize violence based on international custom, and the “National Resistance Front” also finds the status of armed militias that have rebelled against a legitimate government.
I appreciate you sharing your perspective on the situation in Afghanistan. It sounds like you’re highlighting the potential consequences of the international community recognizing the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan.
Let’s open this up for discussion. What are your thoughts on this? Do you agree or disagree with the idea that this recognition could shift the power dynamics between the government and militia groups? How do you feel about the role of the Taliban as a legitimate government and the status of the National Resistance Front as armed militias? Let’s hear from others as well.
Hello!!!
Your dedication to this multifaceted dilemma is significant; feel free to state any supports or critiques you might have.
but if you see, the taliban are educated people,
but they do not understand, why people are seeking for education
Thank you for sharing your observation. It’s interesting to think about the reasons why some educated individuals may not understand the value of education for others. Education can have different meanings and purposes for different people. What are your thoughts on why some educated individuals might not understand the importance of education for others? How do you feel about that?
The previous and current Taliban are different. Today’s Taliban are mostly educated. The previous Taliban did not leave anyone out even without Muharram, but the problem of the current Taliban is that they do not understand each other and are under the pressure of some previous ideas.
Let me make one thing clear, the other day i was sitting in fron sit of the car there were two ppl who belonged to the Taliban. I was using my phone and he was behind me reading the written text.
As conclusion, they do what they want and their big fishes have no control over their followers. I am scared of being kidnapped, killed, or getting arrested. This is not what i think they will do to the people who raise their voice, this is actually we are witnessing every day.
If the government recognize and doors of schools open for girls and women can use from the right that holy Quran give for us this country maybe improve because if one point in a society have Negative rule every thing destroy.
Thank you for sharing that perspective. It’s interesting to hear your view on how the previous and current Taliban differ. I’d like to open this up to the group now. What are your thoughts on this? Do you agree or disagree? How do you feel about that?
Can you see your answer in my last comment
I don’t think if the word recognize them can have affect.
Yes, the Taliban can draw the attention of the international community for their behavior to recognize them, but the Taliban make it difficult for themselves by closing girls’ schools and denying the right to education for women.
1 Like
Thank you for initiating this thought-provoking discussion on the situation in Afghanistan. I believe recognizing the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan could indeed have significant consequences for power dynamics between the government and militia groups. The recognition would potentially legitimize the Taliban’s authority as a government, which may further consolidate their power. However, it raises questions about the status of the National Resistance Front and the implications for armed militias. I look forward to hearing more views on this topic from others as well. Shall we delve deeper into the complexities of this situation?
Thank you, for your insightful comment on the possible consequences of recognizing the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan. It is indeed a complex situation, and I appreciate your willingness to delve deeper into it. I invite others to share their thoughts on this topic as well. What are your opinions or concerns regarding the potential legitimation of the Taliban’s authority and its impact on the National Resistance Front and other armed militias?
Yeah I also heard that they are all not the same they are in different groups with different thoughts and ideas.
That’s an interesting point, thank you for sharing. It seems like you’re suggesting that the individuals we’re discussing are not all the same and have different perspectives. I’m curious to hear from others: do you agree or disagree with this? How do you feel about that?
Yeah absolutely
If they are not the same why their actions are the same? All of them obey the same order.
I hear your question about actions and obedience. It seems like you’re suggesting that if individuals or groups are not the same, their actions might still be similar because they all follow the same orders. Can you please provide more context or specific examples to help us better understand your point of view? What are your thoughts, everyone?
What potential negative consequences can arise in a society if girls and women are not recognized by the government and are denied access to education, despite the rights granted to them in the Holy Quran?