Day 3: Afghanistan Future: Government Recognition_TeamA

I appreciate your input. It seems like you’re highlighting a discrepancy between the recognition of the old regime and the lack of peace that we currently have. To dig deeper into this issue, let’s explore the possible factors contributing to this situation.

Can you elaborate on what you mean by “peace”? What are the specific challenges or conflicts that you believe are preventing peace from being achieved? Take your time to reflect on the various aspects related to this issue.

yes i am agree with you and also it is like a game that they sit one group for this period of time and another group for next period of time and only the people are impress of this game

Yes, there are many other reasons like they banned females not go to parks, swimming pools, picnics, beauty parlor also for males there is no work so obviously the people don’t trust them until they won’t make positive decisions for Afghan nation.

Exactly, but the current government does not have any of the conditions for recognition, so that they do not make changes in their governance system, no country will recognize this government.

1 Like

Before seizing power, the Taliban were at the beginning of an Islamic movement that has a special and extremely conservative interpretation of Islam. They even claim for their lifestyle that they should live like the leader of Islam. In the first round of their coming to power, the Taliban destroyed all the elements. What kind of spiritual things did they ban, they even banned television, radio and cameras

Afghanistan is in a severe political, economic, cultural, social and educational crisis and we all know that the reason for all these disturbances is only the non-recognition of the Taliban government and that’s it.

As it can be seen from interviews, statements of heads of state and diplomatic authorities and some resolutions of global and regional assemblies, the world is still not ready to recognize the new government in Afghanistan, each country sets conditions for this recognition according to its own values, such as preserving the achievements In the last twenty years, without mentioning the positive and negative aspects of it, respect for human rights, civil liberties, freedom of expression and the press, the necessary grounds for women’s participation in social, political, economic activities, government work, education, etc.

I appreciate your input on the recognition of the new government in Afghanistan. It seems that there are several factors and conditions that each country considers before recognizing the government. You mentioned several important values, such as preserving achievements, respecting human rights, civil liberties, and women’s participation in different sectors.

Could you elaborate further on the specific conditions that countries have set for recognizing the new government? Are there any concerns or issues related to these conditions that you would like to highlight? Additionally, do you see any potential challenges or implications that may arise from these conditions?

I completely agree with the statement provided. The Taliban cannot be considered a legal or legitimate government for several reasons. Firstly, a legal and official system should be inclusive, representing all ethnicities and nationalities of Afghanistan. However, the Taliban rule is dominated by the Pashtun ethnic group and does not incorporate the diverse population of the country. This exclusionary approach undermines the principles of democracy, equality, and representation.

Moreover, the Taliban lacks a clear political line and a defined system of laws. Their decisions are arbitrary and do not adhere to internationally accepted human rights standards. They enforce their extremist ideology through violence and intimidation, disregarding the welfare and basic rights of the Afghan people. Such actions represent a flagrant violation of fundamental human values.

Recognizing the Taliban as a legitimate government would not only be illogical but also unjust. It would legitimize their brutal seizure of power and send a message that the international community condones their cruel methods. Upholding the principles of democracy, justice, and inclusiveness is crucial in order to support the rights and wellbeing of all Afghans.

In conclusion, the Taliban’s lack of inclusivity, absence of a well-defined system, and their use of violence clearly demonstrate their inability to be a legal or legitimate government. Recognizing and supporting such a regime would contradict the principles upon which a just and equitable system should be built. It is imperative to advocate for a future in Afghanistan that prioritizes the rights and interests of all its citizens, rather than endorsing a system based on extremism and cruelty.

So, in your opinion, the Taliban do not see the need to be recognized?

I understand your point about the lack of peace despite the recognition of the old regime. This may be attributed to various complex factors, such as historical tensions, conflicting interests, and ongoing challenges. It’s important to delve deeper into these factors to identify potential solutions and pathways towards peace.

I appreciate your insights on the complex factors contributing to the lack of peace despite the recognition of the old regime. It’s crucial to explore those factors in more detail to uncover potential solutions and pathways towards peace. Can you expand on the historical tensions you mentioned? What specific historical events or conflicts do you think have contributed to the current situation?

Absolutely

Exactly this can cause their government to stagnate.

I see what you’re saying. The stagnation of a government can indeed be a significant issue. Can you delve deeper into the factors that contribute to this stagnation? What specific challenges might a government face that lead to this problem?

I think if the Taliban government ensures security in Afghanistan well and do not take any measures to harm other countries, one potential future scenario will be that the international community recognizes the Taliban-led government in Afghanistan.

Yes absolutely right

Hello! I’m glad to see you agree. Could you please elaborate on what you find right about the current topic? What specifically resonates with you?

Yes, the Taliban should think about educating people about economics and rejecting all prohibitions so that the world will accept them

As I think if the Taliban have not put forward any plan for compromise while their forces on Kabul. The international community should deny the Taliban travel privileges from Doha as long as fighting supersedes intra-Afghan talks.